The slides for this presentation can be downloaded in PDF format: Feedback and Grading.

A transcript of the presentation is also available in PDF format: Feedback and Grading Transcript.

Providing Feedback

The following YouTube video is a presentation by Dr. Curtis Bonk, Professor of Education from Indiana University. In this video he provides practical tips and suggestions for providing feedback in the online setting.



Feedback Scenarios

Feedback Scenario 1

In a software development project management course, students are working on a semester-long project that requires them to submit deliverables every two weeks. The students' project proposals are due at the end of Module 3. In the project documentation, the instructor explains that she will approve and provide feedback for the project proposals within one week of the due date (i.e., by the end of Module 4). It is now day 5 of Module 5 and the students have not heard back from the instructor on their project proposals. Their project planning document is due on day 7 of Module 5.

Scenario 1 Prompts

  • How might the students be impacted by the instructor's lack of timely feedback?
  • How might the instructor be impacted by her lack of timely feedback?

Feedback Scenario 2

In an advanced digital filters course, students submit PDF screenshots of lines of code as well as the raw MATLAB m-files as they learn various aspects of designing digital filters each week. The instructor downloads the PDF screenshots and provides annotated feedback in Acrobat Professional. In his annotations, he underlines erroneous parts of the code. He does not explain that his underlinings indicate errors. At the top of the screenshot puts a check-mark and writes, "Ok" and then saves the PDF and returns it to his students.

Scenario 2 Prompts

  • How might the students be impacted by the instructor's lack of meaningful feedback?
  • What could the instructor do to increase the meaningfulness of his feedback?

Additional Resources

The following resources are provided for further study of this topic.

(n.d.). Illinois Online Network: Your source for technology enhanced and online education information. Retrieved February 21, 2013, from http://www.ion.uillinois.edu/resources/tutorials/communication/feedback.asp

Johns Hopkins Medicine. (n.d.). Feedback. Retrieved February 21, 2013, from http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/fac_development/video/flash/feedback.html

(n.d.). Tips for giving online class feedback and constructive criticism. Retrieved February 21, 2013, from http://www.brighthub.com/education/online-learning/articles/35429.aspx

NETnet: The Northeast Texas Distance Learning Consortium. (n.d.). Distance education feedback strategies. Retrieved February 21, 2013, from http://www.netnet.org/instructors/design/interaction/strategies/feedback.htm (Link no longer active at netnet.org)